Changes to the Yeamans
E J Yeaman's Handbook of the Scottish Hills, as published in 1989, contained 2441 hills. Some hills were subsequently shown to fail the criteria for inclusion stated in the Introduction, viz. an ascent of 100m all round, or, failing that, is at least 5km (walking distance) from any higher point on neighbouring hills. In 2001 Yeaman circulated a typed update sheet with some copies of the Handbook which identified 65 new hills, deleted 11 hills, and replaced 6 hills. On later copies of this update sheet one of these replacements was manually scored out.
Later authors building on Yeaman's work adopted a simplified criterion of 100m drop, paving the way for publication of the Humps. Revision of the Yeamans as such ceased with the 2001 update, consequently the list has "historic" status.
Yeaman identified hills by 4-figure grid references. Although this occasionally fails to identify the summit, it reduces the need for alternate tops to be created when Humps or Tumps are relocated as in many cases notional summit relocations have fallen within the same km square. When a Hump or Tump has been relocated to a summit in a different km square we have retained the original location for the Yeaman.
Promotions |
4576 |
Meall Mor |
1A |
5714 |
Druim Ardoch [Creag Bheithe] |
1B |
3969 |
Meall Reamhar |
1C |
8121 |
Clach MacKenny |
1E |
4008 |
Meall a' Chall [Meall a' Chail] |
2B |
4049 |
Creag a' Chuir |
4B |
8285 |
Meall na h-Iolaire |
5A |
6053 |
Creag nan Ceard |
6B |
3100 |
Easter Balloch |
7B |
4125 |
Fasheilach |
7B |
8460 |
Craig Hill |
7B |
608 |
Meall Alvie |
8B |
6227 |
Carn Bad na Caorach |
9A |
6229 |
Hill of Urchany |
9A |
8571 |
Bracken Noits |
9A |
649 |
Cnoc Thulagain |
9B |
4208 |
Cnoc an Tiumpain |
9B |
4647 |
Carn Dearg |
9B |
4648 |
Creag Nighean Iain Duinn [Foyers Hill] |
9B |
6269 |
Carn Choire Odhair |
9B |
4280 |
Ladhar Bheinn North Top |
10B |
3196 |
Sean Mheall |
10C |
923 |
Creag Mhor |
12A |
6595 |
Bad a' Chlamhain |
12A |
960 |
Coinneach Mhor |
13A |
962 |
Sgurr nan Fhir Duibhe |
13A |
3247 |
Baosbheinn East Top |
13A |
4388 |
Sgurr na Bana Mhoraire |
13B |
4410 |
Beinn Tharsuinn Chaol |
14A |
4709 |
Strone Nea |
15A |
6736 |
Beinn Giuthais [Creag na Feola] |
15A |
1090 |
Tom a' Choinnich |
15B |
4718 |
Carn Beag |
15B |
4721 |
Raven Rock |
15B |
6773 |
Beinn an Lochain [Bearn a' Chlaidheimh] |
15B |
9839 |
Cnoc an Daimh |
16A |
6818 |
Creag an Alltan Fhearna |
16D |
4775 |
Creag na h-Iolaire |
16F |
9701 |
Cnoc Breac |
16F |
6898 |
Egnaig Hill |
18A |
6947 |
Cnoc nan Laraich-cloiche |
19A |
10905 |
Cruach Achadh na Craoibhe |
19A |
6968 |
Meall Dubh |
19C |
6986 |
The Saddle |
19C |
10751 |
Corlarach Hill |
19C |
7045 |
Mount of Haddoch |
21A |
4902 |
Hill of Corrachree |
21B |
7073 |
Strone Hill |
21B |
7074 |
Barmekin Hill |
21B |
11773 |
Hill of Blairfowl |
21B |
7086 |
Gossaford |
22 |
11853 |
Evra Houll |
22 |
11942 |
Ward of Browland |
22 |
4943 |
Beinn a' Charnain |
24A |
4950 |
Cleit Faoph [Cleit Faof] |
24A |
12487 |
Cleitseal a Deas |
24A |
4961 |
Trolamul [Trollamul] |
24B |
7195 |
Milljoan Hill |
27B |
13504 |
Guiltree Hill |
27B |
13685 |
Barr Hill |
27B |
5077 |
Barskeoch Hill |
27C |
7262 |
Ox Hill |
27C |
7265 |
Countam |
27C |
5107 |
Corstorphine Hill |
28A |
5132 |
Rachan Hill |
28B |
Deletions |
6093 |
Cairn Gibbs |
7A |
4164 |
Meall an t-Slugain |
8B |
4362 |
Sgurr na Cloiche |
12B |
13040 |
Balgreggie Craigs |
26A |
7197 |
Mull of Miljoan |
27B |
13912 |
William Law |
28A |
7353 |
Tudhope Hill |
28B |
7370 |
Rome Hill |
28B |
7449 |
Wyndburgh Hill |
28B |
7480 |
Philip Law |
28B |
3561 |
Hungry Law |
33 |
Replacements |
7 |
Meall Buidhe replaces 3904 Beinn Leabhain |
1A |
908 |
Sgurr a' Choire-rainich replaces 3228 Sgurr a' Ghlas Leathaid |
12A |
1440 |
Coraddie [Beinn Bhreac] replaces 1442 Beinn Bhreac |
19C |
7084 |
Moss Houl replaces 11906 Sandwater Hill |
22 |
12419 |
Seabhal replaces 7100 Stromacleit |
24A |
12971 |
Stoneyhall Hill* temporarily replaced 7150 Dunearn Hill |
26A |
* manually scored out on later copies of the update sheet |
Changes to the Clems
E D 'Clem' Clements extended Yeaman's criteria to England, Wales and the Isle of Man. Clem's original handwritten list of 1993 comprised 1284 hills. A number of people suggested revisions to the list, including some by Clem in 2004, but a definitive list was never published. Following the approach taken with the Yeamans, only the 14 changes identified by Clem have been accepted into the revised list, which like the Yeamans has "historic" status.
Clem originally called his list Yeamans of England & Wales or Yeomans. After his death they were renamed Clems in recognition of his achievement.
Promotions |
19452 |
Iolyn Park |
30B |
5170 |
Bryn Pydew |
30C |
7592 |
Allt Fawr |
31A |
5226 |
Burfa Bank |
31B |
5248 |
Pen-yr-allt |
31C |
2256 |
Fan Llia |
32A |
5275 |
Mynydd Dinas |
32C |
3861 |
Great How (Thirlmere) |
34B |
19127 |
Whitehills |
35A |
7759 |
Rock Hill |
38A |
7769 |
Crawley Hill [Hetty Pegler's Tump] |
39 |
7812 |
Watership Down |
42 |
18453 |
St Martha's Hill |
42 |
Deletions |
7511 |
Moel Ystradau |
30B |
3509 |
Garn Wen |
31C |
5554 |
Tair Onnen [Tair Onen (Pantylladron)] |
32C |
3561 |
Hungry Law |
33 |
3578 |
Blotting Raise [Croglin Fell] |
35A |
3605 |
Collier Law |
35A |
16226 |
Thiefside Hill |
35A |
Replacements |
3649 |
Great Links Tor replaces 3650 Amicombe Hill |
40 |
Notes and credits
The lists we give were prepared by Bernie Hughes and published on haroldstreet.org.uk in 2013. Hughes retained all the hills listed in the original 1989 publication and augmented them with the 2001 additions and replacements. After consultation with Rob Woodall he took the same approach with the Clems by combining the 1993 list with Clem's 2004 additions and replacements. The DoBIH adopted the same lists when adding them in 2019. As on haroldstreet, all the hills are identified in the DoBIH as Yeamans or Clems without regard to whether they appear on the original or revised list or both.
Yeaman uses Anglicised versions of some Gaelic hill names, and for some hills a general name that has been superseded by a more precise summit name. These names are not given in the DoBIH unless they were present before the addition of the Yeamans.
|